Skip to main content

Guest Reviews

See What Past Guests Are Saying About Their Experience

Warm, friendly service, supremely comfortable rooms and a convenient location in the heart of Midtown Manhattan bring guests back to the San Carlos Hotel again and again. If you're planning a visit to NYC, we welcome you to read the hotel reviews below to experience our boutique hotel through the eyes of your fellow travelers. Winners of The Certificate Of Excellence for 5 years in a row! 

Loved our visit - felt as if we were coming home - and that is why we stay here every year! Loved our room overlooking East 50th, loved the holiday decorations, and love, love, love the friendly and caring staff. I look forward to seeing them every visit - it's the same employees each time - and it's like being greeted by friends! See you soon San Carlos!!!! even if I have to wait until next December we will be back!

Jhon D

We stayed here for 4 nights with our 3 children aged 5, 12 & 18. The staff were so friendly & helpful. We had a one bedroom apartment which was perfect. Was so clean & very spacious. The kids loved having free wifi In the bedroom. The continental breakfast was great, enough choice for all & set us up until lunchtime. It was freezing outside but room was always warm. Bathroom was a perfect size & shower had lots of hot water. We had dinner in the restaurant Spice Symphony which was really good too. Reception were great for arranging family restaurants for us. We will definitely comeback to this hotel as was a great find & within walking distance to most attractions.

Hodor H

We've stayed in many NYC hotels and this was a total winner. The rooms are large with plush bedding, and nice amenities. It's meticulously clean, the location is ideal, the price is right, and the service is top notch. The little touches made us feel at home: umbrellas, free NYT and USAToday, chocolates! The elevator comes quickly. A real person answers the phone. We checked in with no wait. AND, you can open the windows and let in the fresh air! We'll be back again for sure.

Duis aute irure ​